Autor: Vindex (vindex_at_friko.onet.pl)
Data: Sun 04 Oct 1998 - 22:41:05 MET DST
Poniewaz wokol tej karty nagromadzilo sie wiele watpliwosci
postanowilem sam ja przetestowac. Do testow dostalem karte Hercules
Terminator Beast w wersji OEM. Zeby nie bylo watpliwosci - support
Hercules'a potwierdzil ze jest to wersja _koncowa_ karty wiec nie
zadne tam rev. A chipa. Karta zainstalowala sie bez wiekszych
problemow - gorzej bylo z dzialaniem. Przy szynie 83 MHz uruchomienie
czegokolwiek zwiazanego z 3D konczylo sie "zwisem". Przy 75 MHz bylo
troche lepiej ale tez nie idealnie - dopiero przy 66 MHz karta
chodzila stabilnie. Najnowsze sterowniki Hercules'a dawaly dosc
przyzwoite wyniki w 2D ale d3d bylo bardzo problematyczne - bledy w
wyswietlaniu grafiki (incoming i NFS3), mala stabilnosc (wieszanie
final reality) itp. Na szczescie sa rowniez dostepne sterowniki S3 -
one rowniez nie sa pozbawione bledow ale sa przynajmniej w miare
stabilne. Poza kilkoma bledami w wyswietlaniu (NFS3 - napisy i drobne
bledy w trakcie gry, drobne bledy w Turok'u) i _beznadziejna_
wydajnoscia 2D sprawowaly sie nie najgorzej - w 3D byly nawet szybsze
od Hercules'owych. Ponizej wyniki testow.
Konfiguracja:
C333 @ 333
P2B, 128 MB SDRAM
Hercules Terminator Beast 8MB(savage 3D)
Millenium G200 SG 8MB
Monster 2 8MB
Wszystkie karty pracowaly z wylaczonym vsync i na nominalnych
czestotliwosciach
turok g200 Savage V2
640/480 70.4 53.0 68.0
800/600 55.8 40.1 56.7
QUAKE 2
640/480 38.6 83.1
800/600 30.7 72.0
Incoming
640/480 59.33 46.23 54.31
800/600 41.92 36.33 52.27
Final Reality 1.01
Database Entry <C333 Savage 3D>
Benchmark results:
Radial blur, 5N, 31.77, rips, 4.394, Rmark
Chaos zoomer, 5N, 50.63, rips, 2.460, Rmark
25 Pixel, 5N, 166.10, kpps, 5.308, Rmark
Robots, 5N, 33.91, rips, 8.786, Rmark
Fillrate, 5N, 22.50, MPps, 4.870, Rmark
City scene, 5N, 44.31, rips, 10.996, Rmark
Video card bus transfer, 5N, 41.27, MBps, 1.314, Rmark
Direct3D bus transfer, 5N, 28.10, MBps, 2.402, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Visual appearance, 100.00, percent
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall 3D, 3.307, Rmark
Overall 2D, 3.427, Rmark
Overall bus rate, 1.640, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
OVERALL SCORE, 3.093, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2142752647
Database Entry <C333 Monster 2> (monster + savage)
Benchmark results:
Radial blur, 5N, 32.84, rips, 4.542, Rmark
Chaos zoomer, 5N, 53.20, rips, 2.585, Rmark
25 Pixel, 5N, 177.55, kpps, 5.674, Rmark
Robots, 5N, 41.53, rips, 10.760, Rmark
Fillrate, 5N, 53.66, MPps, 11.614, Rmark
City scene, 5N, 55.62, rips, 13.801, Rmark
Video card bus transfer, 5N, 40.37, MBps, 1.285, Rmark
Direct3D bus transfer, 5N, 28.02, MBps, 2.395, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Visual appearance, 100.00, percent
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall 3D, 3.832, Rmark
Overall 2D, 3.564, Rmark
Overall bus rate, 1.618, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
OVERALL SCORE, 3.419, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3243649954
Database Entry <C333 G200>
Benchmark results:
Radial blur, 5N, 32.10, rips, 4.440, Rmark
Chaos zoomer, 5N, 50.47, rips, 2.452, Rmark
25 Pixel, 5N, 197.56, kpps, 6.314, Rmark
Robots, 5N, 41.68, rips, 10.798, Rmark
Fillrate, 5N, 63.93, MPps, 13.837, Rmark
City scene, 5N, 51.60, rips, 12.805, Rmark
Video card bus transfer, 5N, 148.34, MBps, 4.723, Rmark
Direct3D bus transfer, 5N, 96.54, MBps, 8.251, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Visual appearance, 92.59, percent
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall 3D, 3.714, Rmark
Overall 2D, 3.446, Rmark
Overall bus rate, 5.781, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
OVERALL SCORE, 3.944, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
964154191
Database Entry <C333 g200 + Monster 2>
Benchmark results:
Radial blur, 5N, 32.33, rips, 4.472, Rmark
Chaos zoomer, 5N, 51.67, rips, 2.511, Rmark
25 Pixel, 5N, 205.95, kpps, 6.582, Rmark
Robots, 5N, 46.36, rips, 12.011, Rmark
Fillrate, 5N, 53.61, MPps, 11.605, Rmark
City scene, 5N, 61.52, rips, 15.265, Rmark
Video card bus transfer, 5N, 155.18, MBps, 4.940, Rmark
Direct3D bus transfer, 5N, 79.33, MBps, 6.780, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Visual appearance, 100.00, percent
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall 3D, 4.010, Rmark
Overall 2D, 3.491, Rmark
Overall bus rate, 5.492, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
OVERALL SCORE, 4.077, Rmark
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3042970438
Millenium g200 savage (ster. Hercules'a) savage
(ster. s3)
Winbench 97
Bussines 131 120 85
Highend 71.9 67.4 34.7
Jak widac karcie tej daleko do "VooDoo 2 killer'a" - mozliwe ze wyniki
na nowszych sterownikach beda lepsze ale narazie karta jest typowym
produktem S3
Pozdrowienia
Vindex
To archiwum zostało wygenerowane przez hypermail 2.1.7 : Tue 18 May 2004 - 17:41:25 MET DST